The Day After After learning of Max's departure, Cappie wonders if he made the right decision by telling Casey he wasn't interested in giving their relationship another chance, while Casey struggles with the aftermath of Cappie's unexpected rejection; Rebecca's late night kiss with a mystery man can't stay a secret for too long; and Rusty risks failing in o-chem and losing his honor status, while roommate Dale faces a huge moral dilemma. And if campus drama weren't enough, add family dynamics to the mix as ZBZ celebrates father-daughter weekend, with Ashleigh's father Brian, Rebecca's father Senator Ken Logan, Jordan's father Jack and Casey's father Russell. Thanks to their less than stellar pledge class, the ZBZ house also begins sliding in the ranks among the other sorority houses. Casey, Rebecca and Ashleigh do everything they can to maintain their status as one of the top houses at Cyprus Rhodes. ZBZ pledge Abby drives Casey crazy when she expresses her disappointment in the lack of party invites and questions the sorority's relationship with the popular fraternities. Also, a new hottie waitress, Lana, hits the Cyprus-Rhodes scene and captures the eye of a big man on campus.
Our Fathers Casey solves the mystery of the man Rebecca locked lips with during the End of the World party and tries to keep it a secret. But Rebecca admits to the scandal herself, causing a huge fight amongst the ladies of the ZBZ house. When their fathers arrive for the Daddy/Daughter weekend, they wind up getting pulled into the drama! Meanwhile, Rusty is nervous about impressing Jordan's father who expects a jock over a science nerd. Rusty goes against Calvin's advice and tries to win him over by playing aggressively during a game of flag football leading to painful results! Upset over the loss of his virginity, Dale visits his pastor to seek forgiveness, which leads him and Cappie on a journey to explore different religions. They wind up meeting a Catholic schoolgirl, Mary-Elyse, whom both guys are interested in for very different reasons.
The Half-Naked Gun As Rusty and Jordan are awkwardly deciding when to take their relationship to the next level, the Gotcha Game comes between them as the final two players left in the game. Cappie becomes Rusty's bodyguard and Rebecca becomes Jordan's, as the happy couple battle it out so their house can win the game. Casey takes over as the ZBZ Panhellenic delegate, butting heads with the president, Katherine, over the annual "Undie Run". After Katherine has the event canceled, Casey uses Evan's help to get enough signatures to overturn the decision and save the traditional event. Casey turns the run into a charity cause by donating everyone's clothes to the homeless. Meanwhile, Calvin and Grant are trying desperately to find some alone time so they can be together away from their raucous Omega Chi brothers. In the end, they decide to leave campus for a romantic dinner, but are surprised when Evan is one of their waiters!
High And Dry It's Dry Weekend at Cyprus Rhodes University, and Casey plans a non-alcohol party night amongst all of the houses. But when she and Evan are partnered together to patrol each of the houses for signs of any prohibited beverages, they each have a brownie at the Psi Phi house unaware of its secret ingredient causing them to hide out in the ZBZ bathroom until the effects wear off. Meanwhile, Ashleigh frantically tries to find Casey, and Fisher offers to help, making her further question whether or not she should take him back. Grant's high school girlfriend, Whitney, surprises Grant (and Calvin) by visiting for his birthday. Calvin enlists Rebecca's help on a double date as he patiently waits for Grant to tell Whitney the truth about himself. Rusty learns that he earned a new nickname in the engineering school because of his slipping grades. He decides to approach the infamous Dr. Larsen at his book signing event to see if he will sponsor Rusty in an experiment. Cappie joins him for moral support and attempts to flirt with the engineering girls.
Down On Your Luck Shocked to learn that ZBZ has slipped in the ranks down to fourth, Casey is determined to bring ZBZ back to the number one spot by motivating their pledge class to take action! Casey believes that, if they create a cool photo shoot for the Lamda Sig calendar, it could improve their house's ranking. However, freshman pledge Abby leads a revolution with the other ZBZ pledges to boycott the photo shoot! Dissatisfied with her college experience, Jordan wonders how to make her time at CRU more fulfilling. In an effort to prove his love and commitment for Jordan as well as to cheer her up Rusty decides to lavaliere her. When Rusty divulges his plans to his KT brothers, they warn him of the Kappa Tau curse that occurs when a brother lavalieres his girlfriend. Meanwhile, Cappie helps Evan find a part time job to help his financial situation, but when he meets one of Evan's new and very attractive - co-workers, Lana, he decides to get a job too!
Lost And Founders It's Founders Weekend at the ZBZ house and the girls decide to keep the house's decline in the rankings a secret in hopes they can hustle enough donations to meet their goals. As a result, Casey creates a plan to suck up to Doris McGovern, the wealthiest ZBZ alum, while Ashleigh and Rebecca, still feuding over the Fisher incident, start their own competition on who can raise the most money. Jordan and Rusty double date with Calvin and Grant, but Rusty is uneasy since Grant was one of the Omega Chi brothers who taped him to a wall. Calvin tries to divert the conversation to protect Grant from an uncomfortable situation. While Jordan, still not happy at Cyprus Rhodes University (CRU), realizes her passion for photography and considers taking an internship in New York, Rusty is determined to keep Jordan at CRU and tries to help her get accepted into the school's photography program. Meanwhile, Evan and Cappie continue working at their part time catering job together. Cappie's real agenda scoring a date with sexy waitress Lana (Olivia Munn) comes into play as he takes her out for a drink at Doblers, where he runs into Casey and Nate, the assistant to Doris McGovern, who is quite the hottie.
The Dork Knight As Evan and Cappie's friendship grows stronger, Casey is on a mission to find out what's happening between them. When Casey tries to trick Cappie into telling her, a brawl starts between the KT's and OX's, leaving Casey with no answers. However Casey's sheer determination leads her to follow Cappie into the Amphora Lair. Will Casey's detective work risk Cappie and Evan's newfound friendship and the secrecy of the Amphora's society? Rusty, Dale and Calvin decide to take a trip to Comic-Con to take Rusty's mind off Jordan. On the way, Rusty meets an "Alien Girl" also going to the event. In the crowd of superheroes and Martians, Rusty manages to find her, but is too anxious for a relationship and scares her off. Rusty is struggling to let go of Jordan and decides to Skype her with a Comic-Con computer the same computer hooked up to the big screen for the Q&A taking place with John De Lancie. Back at CRU, Ashleigh and Fisher begin dating again, but they both feel like they have to walk on egg shells around each other and continue to have trust issues.
Fight The Power In Casey and Ashleigh's continuing struggle to bring ZBZ back to the top, Ashleigh decides a four-way mixer is the best way to gain their popularity back. But when her invite to the Gamma Psi sorority is turned down, she offers to pay the Gamma Psi's electric bill if they agree to attend. Utilizing the money ZBZ received from Founder's Day, Ashleigh goes all out for the party, including ice sculptures, caricatures and an open bar. Evan's secret about his trust fund is spreading around campus and his reputation in Omega Chi is crumbling. As a result, Evan explains the drama to Casey, who is taken back - and yet proud - by Evan's decision to lose his trust fund and support himself. Just as Cappie and Lana's relationship begins to grow, Cappie starts blowing Lana off for no apparent reason. So Rusty, who is trying to figure out what is missing from Cappie's love life, takes matters into his own hands and tries to bring them back together. Meanwhile, Rebecca is spending her evening at the mixer teaching the pledges how to flirt, while Calvin begins to question his relationship with Grant.
The Wish-Pretzel Everyone is packing their bags and heading home for Thanksgiving, but Casey and Rusty find themselves stranded at CRU when their parents leave them behind for Maui. Fortunately for Rusty, he quickly realizes he has other friends who stayed on campus as well. Casey thinks she has the ZBZ house to herself, but Rebecca joins her after she decides not to go home either. Due to Casey's ongoing streak of bad karma, she and Rebecca decide to volunteer their time by delivering food to the elderly, but too many volunteers show up and their help is turned down. The girls decide to host an "orphan Thanksgiving" at the ZBZ house with frozen pizza for everyone left behind at CRU. Evan and Cappie are also stuck at CRU for the weekend and see this as a perfect opportunity for them to hang out and play golf. When Cappie realizes he has the annual KT Turkey Hunt, he cancels on Evan to help his brothers follow the final clue which leads to the OX house. Meanwhile, Rusty and Dale plan to host a Thanksgiving dinner feast, but when Rusty begins to make some headway on his engineering project, the dinner is canceled. Feeling the heat of the competition over the grant they are both fighting for, Dale struggles with his project and sneaks into the lab to read Rusty's notes. Then, the KT's step in to host the dinner, and in the spirit of the holiday, Evan is invited to join. After a surprisingly calm dinner, Cappie decides to walk Casey home, in hopes of telling her how he really feels.
Friend Or Foe One of the biggest blue ribbon competitions Songfest is approaching and the ZBZs are determined to win. But Panhellenic president Katherine offers Casey a VP position forcing Casey to choose between furthering her position in Panhellenic or helping the ZBZs win. Katherine throws a second curveball to the ZBZs by disqualifying their dance the night before the competition. ZBZ pledge Abby offers to save the day by choreographing an all new dance. Will they make it work and win the competition? And the Omega Chi and Kappa Tau rivalry heats up when the OXs fill the KT house with crickets. Cappie and Evan launch a plan in hopes of uniting their houses but will it bring them together or push them even further apart? Meanwhile, Rusty and Dale are feuding over their science projects and decide the best way to settle the score is a good old fashioned battle bots competition.
